Stop Using the Wrong Shopify Free Gift With Purchase Apps! Here's my 2 Picks After Testing 7 Top Contenders
If you’re looking to boost sales and make your customers super happy at the same time, I’ve got a secret weapon for you: Shopify gift with purchase apps. I’ve spent countless hours testing these tools on many stores, and I’m pumped to share what actually works.
Let me tell you – watching your average order value climb while customers rave about their free gifts? That feeling never gets old! Let’s dive into the absolute best Shopify apps for running these promotions in 2025.
Quick showdown: Top 7 Shopify Gift with Purchase Apps
1. Feature Comparison Table: Which is the best app?
✴️ Best in category
✔️ Feature available
❌ Feature unavailable
| App Name | Auto Add Free Gift | Gift Progress Bar | Pop-ups & Notifications | Upsell/Bundles | Custom Rules | FOMO Triggers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BOGO+ Free Gift & Buy X Get Y | ✴️ | ❌ | ✴️ | ✴️ | ✴️ | ✔️ |
| Snap Slide Cart Progress Bar | ✔️ | ✴️ | ❌ | ✴️ | ✔️ | ✴️ |
| Sales Motivator Free Gifts | ✔️ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ | ❌ |
| Gift Box | ✴️ | ✔️ | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ | ❌ |
| qikify Upsell BOGO & Free Gift | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✴️ | ✴️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| BOGOS.io Free Gift BOGO Bundle | ✴️ | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ | ✔️ | ❌ |
| Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts | ✔️ | ✴️ | ❌ | ✴️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
2. Other Criteria Comparison Table: Pricing, Customer Support, Rating & more
| App Name | Price Range | Support Quality | User Rating | Performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BOGO+ Free Gift & Buy X Get Y | Free to $47.99 / month | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Friendly & fast | 4.8 ⭐ (228) | 🚀 Smooth & reliable |
| Snap Slide Cart Progress Bar | Free | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Friendly & fast | 5.0 ⭐ (3) | ⚡ Lightweight & clean |
| Sales Motivator Free Gifts | Free to $29.99/month | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Helpful support | 4.8 ⭐ (194) | ✅ Stable |
| Gift Box | Free to $99.99/month | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Helpful support | 4.8 ⭐ (205) | ✅ Fast-loading |
| qikify Upsell BOGO & Free Gift | Free to $49.99/month | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Effective support team | 4.9 ⭐ (1078) | ⚙️ Versatile |
| BOGOS.io Free Gift BOGO Bundle | Free to $99.99/month | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Effective support team | 4.9 ⭐ (2668) | 🔄 Efficient |
| Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts | Free to $21.99/month | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⯪ Responsive support team | 4.8 ⭐ (657) | 🛠️ Highly configurable |
My 2 Top Picks of Shopify Free Gift Apps After Tesing 🧠
After installing these apps on my stores (and seeing how the features work and the actual results), two clear winners emerged that I just can’t stop recommending if you truly need a free gift promotion that works on your Shopify store:
When selecting the best Shopify free gift with purchase app, I focused on several key criteria but these 5 criteria made me pick the 2 apps that I will tell you about below:
- 🙏 Features that work smoothly on your store
- 💅 Ease of setup
- 🏋️ Strong performance
- 💁 Reasonable pricing
- 🌷Last but not least, responsive support
1. BOGO+ Free Gift & Buy X Get Y - Best app for automatically ddd free gifts to Cart
BOGO+ Free Gift & Buy X Get Y is hands-down my go-to recommendation when clients want to automatically add free gifts to cart on Shopify.
Here’s why it dominates:
- Creates literally any promotion type: set up buy 1 get 1 free on Shopify, Buy X Get Y, free gift promotion and quantity discounts.
- Automatically adds free gifts when customers hit targets (zero friction!)
- Lets shoppers choose their own gift (this feature alone boosts conversion rates dramatically)
- Includes attention-grabbing widgets like countdown timers and progress bars
- Scales perfectly from small stores to major operations
What really sets BOGO+ apart is how it grabs attention. Those countdown timers? The gift popups? They’re like catnip for shoppers. In the review, one beauty store owner said they saw an x2 in CRV after adding the gift with purchase promotion to their store!
The pricing is super fair too. You can literally use it for FREE until you hit $50 in monthly revenue. After that, plans range from $17.99 to $47.99 based on your Shopify plan. I typically start my smaller clients on the Basic plan and they rarely need to upgrade.
We had one retail client who implemented the “spend $75, choose your free deluxe sample” feature and his average order jumped from $62 to $81 in the first month. Setting it up took maybe 15 minutes tops.
2. BOGO+ Free Gift & Buy X Get Y – Best Free Shopify Cart Progress Bar with Free Gifts App
Snap Slide Cart Progress Bar is honestly my secret weapon recommendation, especially for clients on tight budgets. Why? Because it’s COMPLETELY FREE but performs like a premium app.
This app allows you to set up a cart drawer with a free gift reward if you reach a minimum order amount. Additionally, it also allows you to add a free shipping progress bar to Shopify or a discount bar.
What makes it my #2 pick:
- Custom slide-out cart drawer that perfectly matches your branding
- Progress bars that visually show “spend $15 more for a free gift!”
- Sticky add-to-cart buttons that follow shoppers around your store
- Trust badges and shipping protection right in the cart
- “Reserved for X minutes” timers that create serious FOMO
The reviews don’t lie. One German store owner mentioned how support rep Alice jumped in immediately when they had questions. That level of service for a free app? Mind-blowing.
The results speak for themselves. On a home goods store I know, they shared after adding the progress bar with the “spend $100 for a free candle” messaging cut cart abandonment by 17% and boosted the average order by $23. For exactly $0 in app costs, you can copy their success. Why not try it today!
This my quick setting cart free gift upsell guide with Snap Cart Drawer
- Step 1: You choose a template that includes a progress bar
- Step 2: In “Cart”, configure your progress bar tiers
- Step 3: For example, I set my second tier as a a free gift
- Reward type: Product
- Reward Description: I wrote “A free tote bag”
- Minimum amount: $500
- Text before completing tier: I adjusted to “…. away from a free tote bag”
- Add new reward: set your free gift products, here’s a tote bag.
- Step 4: Save and test how it works in your storefront
Tadaa! This is how it’s displayed in my store. It looks great, right?
Real Talk: Implementation Tips That Actually Work
After setting up these apps on dozens of stores, here’s what actually moves the needle:
- Hit the sweet spot with thresholds – Set gift qualification at 20-30% above your current average order
- Make gifts matter – Choose items that complement what customers are already buying (a makeup brush with foundation, not random keychains)
- Create exclusivity – Use “exclusive” or “not sold separately” gifts that can’t be purchased normally
- Build urgency – “This week only” or “While supplies last” messaging works wonders
- A/B test your visuals – Try different progress bar styles and messages to see what converts
- Stack strategies – Align your free gift threshold with your free shipping threshold
- Keep it fresh – Rotate gifts monthly or seasonally to keep regular customers excited
Bottom Line: Which App Is Right For Your Store?
After all my testing and client implementations, here’s my straight-up advice:
If you want the complete package with automatic gift addition and attention-grabbing visuals, BOGO+ Free Gift & Buy X Get Y is your best bet. The free-until-$50-revenue model means there’s zero risk to try it.
Working with a tight budget? Snap Slide Cart Progress Bar delivers incredible value as a completely free solution focused on cart drawer upsell features.
Whatever app you choose, gift with purchase promotions flat-out work. One of my apparel clients saw a 34% jump in average order value within two weeks of implementation. Start simple, track your results, and scale what works for your unique store.
Have you tried any of these apps? Drop a comment below with your experience – I’d love to hear what’s working for your store!
Best Cart Drawer Upsell App: Snap Slide Cart Progress Bar
Sophia Dao is a Shopify Conversion Specialist at WizzCommerce, specializing in e-commerce and Shopify solutions. With a passion for digital marketing and a keen eye for detail, Sophia creates engaging content that helps businesses thrive online. When she’s not writing, she enjoys exploring the latest trends in tech and commerce. Follow Sophia for practical e-commerce tips and the latest marketing insights!
